Summary
How we reviewed the proposals
Each proposal was checked against the same six things the brief asked for.
1Understands the brief2Two or three visual ideas3Platform, security, maintenance
4Live by end of December5Costs split clearly6Team and relevant projects
How the costs compare
Core build cost for each proposal, in pounds, excluding VAT. Where an agency priced every optional extra, the line shows the total with all of them added. Hover over a bar for the detail.
Shortlisted
Other proposals
Quoted as a range
With all extras
Cosmos and GRAND st. quoted in US dollars, converted at about $1.34 to the pound; their bars run from their lowest to their highest quote. Cosmos and GRAND st. haven't priced their extras. Greensplash and Leap price some extras per item or per story, so there's no single total for them. Upqode didn't send a proposal.
See the figures as a table
The shortlist
The three agencies going forward, as Hanna asked. Click any image to see it full size.
The other proposals
Reviewed in the same way. Open any card for the full detail.